The Sneaky Lease Clause That Could Have Cost My Client Everything

 

Not long ago, I advised a client who was looking to purchase a local business. Everything seemed straightforward: the Contract of Sale included a lease with a year left to run, plus two further options of five years each. On the surface, it looked like my client would have secure tenure for over a decade.

But contracts often hide surprises. Buried deep in the fine print was a clause that read:

“No commitment has been given or intimation made by the Lessor or anyone on its behalf that the Lessor will give a further lease of the premises after the terminating date.”

This clause directly contradicted the lease’s “options to renew.” If enforced, those options would be worthless. When I raised the issue and requested its removal, the landlord refused.

I advised my client not to proceed with the purchase — after all, who wants to buy a business without guaranteed premises beyond one year? It was a near miss that could have cost them their livelihood.

In my 29 years of legal practice, this remains one of the most underhanded examples of drafting I’ve seen. Sadly, it’s also a stark reminder that contracts are often designed to protect the other party — not you.

The lesson? Always have an experienced solicitor review your contracts before you sign. What looks like a great deal may, in fact, be someone else’s problem waiting to land in your lap.

Legal Essentials when Buying Real Estate

Legal Essentials when Buying Real Estate What you Need to Know Understanding the process of buying real estate & avoiding the common traps Legal Essentials when Buying Real Estate. Real estate can be a good investment but it pays to do your homework. As...

Kalde Legal ReviewsGoogle reviews
★★★★★

“Kalde Legal has a 5.0 Google rating based on 21 reviews.”

— Google Reviews
★★★★★

“I've used Eric's services on more than one occasion and have always found him to be professional, knowledgeable, and reliable. During our most recent matter, he handled a very challenging situation with professionalism, compassion, and calm guidance after unexpected circumstances arose just before settlement. His cooperation were greatly appreciated throughout the process. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend him to anyone looking for an excellent Lawyer.”

— Jan (June 2026)
★★★★★

“We worked with Eric and Kalde Legal for the purchase of our very first business in Sydney. Our experience from the very first conversation with Eric, until completion of settlement was nothing short of phenomenal. Eric is thorough, professional, reliable and empathetic. He took the necessary time to understand our situation and provide advice that would protect our interests. I would highly recommend Kalde Legal for their exceptional legal services.”

— Prath (24 June 2026)
★★★★★

“I recently sold my Commercial Property. Eric Kaldelegal was recommended by my Agent. He is very professional, a good communicator, organised and articulate. Very happy. Thanks Eric”

— Mel Olsen
★★★★★

“Eric was an absolute pleasure to deal with - efficient, punctual, responsive and clearly explained everything at every step of the way. Would highly recommend.”

— Anna-Marie Stella
★★★★★

“Eric & Kalde Legal have managed our staff and client legal matters efficiently and with expertise for many years. Always professional and reliable. Moreover, he is also incredibly friendly and approachable. Thank you as always team!”

— Sutton Anderson
★★★★★

“I recently had the pleasure of working with Kalde Legal, and I couldn't be more impressed with their services. They provided invaluable contract advice and business advice that was both clear and practical, helping me navigate complex agreements with confidence.”

— Murray Slee
★★★★★

“Eric assisted me in preparing my will & also managed my father’s estate. I felt comfort in knowing Eric’s advice was clear, concise & comprehensive. He was prompt & professional throughout the whole process.”

— Alex Wilson
★★★★★

“I have currently been looking at leasing a commercial space. Eric was extremely helpful in helping me navigate the complexities involved that I had no idea would be part of a lease. Lifesaver.”

— Amanda King
View Google Reviews